Baseball Playoffs Party

One of my favorite things about October is that all of my favorite sports are back in full swing. Speaking of swing, it is the most exciting month of baseball in October because the playoffs are starting.  And even more spectacular for all of my fellow Chicagoans??? THE CUBS ARE IN THE PLAYOFFS!  Who knows how long they will last in this year’s playoffs (it is a one game playoff—which has had my stomach in knots ALL week), but I’m throwing a baseball playoffs party anyway and want to share my baseball themed ideas with you.


This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase using one of these links, I will earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.


Take Me Out to the Ball Game Trail Mix—I’m just going to say it…I really don’t like Cracker Jacks.  But I LOVE trail mix.  My favorite combo?  Popcorn, honey roasted peanuts, raisins, and chocolate chips.  In Cubbie red and blue, of course.

Baseball Toast—Trim a slice of bread using a circular cookie cutter.  Toast to desired temperature.  Then top with any type of red jam you prefer (strawberry, cherry, mixed berry, etc.) to make the threads of a baseball.

Pretzel and Cheese Skewers—There is nothing better than getting a warm pretzel with cheese at the ball park.  Put an “at home” spin on it by skewering chunks of soft pretzels and cheddar cheese.  No soft pretzels on hand?  No worries.  Regular pretzels work too.

Baseball Pancake—Prepare pancakes as you normally would.  Dice any red fruit (strawberry, raspberry, cranberry, cherry, etc.) and arrange them in lines to make the threads of a baseball.  You can (and should) also put a little Chicago spin on a pancake or two as well.

Hot Dog Bar—A baseball game isn’t complete without a hot dog.  But you really need to up your hot dog game if you are in MY city.  So for our hot dog bar, we make sure to get buns WITH poppy seeds, celery salt, kosher dill pickles and sport peppers, mounds of diced cucumbers, tomatoes, and onions for toppings, as well as relish and mustard.  Some people would fight you on having ketchup at your hot dog bar, but I won’t eat a red hot without it (I know, banish me from the city limits, Chicago).

PB&J Sammies—Similar to the baseball toast, cut out two circular pieces of bread to make your peanut butter and jelly sandwich.  Just save some jelly to draw some baseball lines on the top of the sammie.  Have wipes nearby to tackle those sticky fingers!

Fruit Platter—Spell out your team’s logo and show your pride in a healthy way.  This is a great side to the other carb heavy options that are deliciously fun to eat while watching a game.



Old Style Beer

Yep, there’s really no getting around it.  Old Style is the quintessential Cubs drink.  And you MUST drink it out of a can or it just simply doesn’t count.


One of my favorite memories as a kid is going to baseball games with my Dad and him indulging my sister and I with every chocolate treat he could find (I now realize it was just because HE was the total chocoholic).  So instead of having some chocolate ice cream (it is currently c o l d in Chicago), have a milk shake instead.  Here is the most drool worthy list of milk shakes imaginable. And I like to let my boys decorate their milkshakes with whatever colored sprinkles they like—but I’m only offering blue and red sprinkles this playoff season.



Well, obviously, the two teams have the whole “baseball game” thing covered.  But sometimes baseball can be painfully s  l   o  w.  That’s why I have come up with a few ideas to keep the night moving.

Playoff Predictions

Similar to March Madness, you can set up a bracket of sorts to have everyone guess who they think will end up sporting World Series rings this year.  But to put a Wrigley Field spin to it, I like to use green construction paper and white chalk for the set up.  Doesn’t it just scream “Take Me Out to the Ballgame?”

Baseball Keepsake

Even though your team might not win, one of the best parts about watching your team in the playoffs is making memories with friends and family you watch the game with.  I mean, ask any Cubs fan, and we know EXACTLY where we were during the foul ball incident of 2003.  Sigh.  So to keep reliving some great memories, have everyone write a little note on a baseball (or go totally Chicago style and get a 16” softball—there’s more room to write) to serve as a keepsake.

Play Ball!

About five times a day I tell my boys not to throw balls in the house, but I’m going to let this rule slide come baseball playoff time.  Instead, I am going to encourage them to use a (soft) baseball to knock down towers (made of red solo cups) and focus on strategy and skill instead of breaking fragile things in the house.  Maybe one of them will emerge as a southpaw and will be playing in October a decade or two from now.



Whether you are a South Sider or North Sider, you need to be dressed to the nines during the playoffs. And if your lucky shirt doesn’t get so lucky after the first game of the series? You need to head over to the MLB Shop for some new, lucky threads of course!


I’m sure I could go on and on about baseball décor, but I get the most pleasure out of delicious food and drinks and making lasting memories with my family and friends.  Feel free to browse Pinterest (and follow me while you’re on there) for other outstanding ideas.

And if you are heading to Wrigley (with or without kids), be sure to read this list of tips FIRST!

Play Ball and Go CUBS Go!


Don’t miss a post…follow me on Blog Lovin.’


    • amandasimkin says

      Whoever wins (between my husband and I) gets a night off from doing dishes for a week. Cross your fingers for me!

  1. Stephanie says

    That looks like a lot of fun! I almost wish I had baseball fans in my house – although that would mean I’d have to fight for the TV during the world series!

    • amandasimkin says

      Thanks for the baseball support. It’s baseball hysteria in Chicago right now for sure (at least on the North Side).

  2. Heather says

    We aren’t baseball people, But we are huge football people, and tend to throw a party if our teams get into the Super Bowl. I love that ice cream and the m&m popcorn!

    • amandasimkin says

      I’m sure we will have some football themed parties once the baseball hype is over in Chicago (and hopefully the Cubs win the World Series).

  3. Alli says

    I’m a Braves fan. I started going to their games in Atlanta when I was just a little girl. I’ve seen lots of the greats play (Hank Aaron). That trail mix looks amazing. I need to make up a batch.

    • amandasimkin says

      Wow, that must have been awesome to see Hank Aaron play. I feel that way about seeing Michael Jordan play basketball all the time when I was a little girl.

  4. Jeanine says

    What a fun idea! I love parties like this. Celebrating playoffs would be such fun. I wish my kiddos were in sports currently but none of them are as of now!

    • amandasimkin says

      Who knows maybe one day they will be interested in sports…there are so many interesting and exciting things to choose from!

  5. Brittany says

    Super fun party idea! I love how you used the strawberries to make the pancake look like a baseball. I will need to remember this for when my little guy starts to get into sports!

    • amandasimkin says

      The only problem with the PB&J sammies is that they can get a little messy. But with two little boys I am VERY used to messy! 😉

    • amandasimkin says

      It would be great for a baseball themed birthday party too…but since Chicago is celebrating the Cubs in the playoffs right now, we are planning on a week long party!

    • amandasimkin says

      It’s a long season but I always think watching the way beginning and the end of the season is the best!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.